AI Agent: emails from template or fully personalized?
Your AI agent can follow a strict template or create each email from scratch. Both have their strengths and pitfalls. This article helps you choose the right approach for your situation, and how to combine both when relevant.
- The template guarantees control, free writing guarantees adaptation.
- The hybrid solution (template with free zones) combines the advantages of both.
- Always test with a dry run before launching a new agent.
When you create an AI agent to manage your emails, a question comes up quickly: should you give it a model to follow or let it write each message from scratch? The answer is not the same for everyone. It depends on what you send, to whom, and the level of control you need. Many executives start at one extreme, then correct course. This article saves you that detour.
IWhat is an email template for an AI agent?
A message template that the agent follows to write their emails.
The template defines the structure, the tone, sometimes exact phrases. The agent fills in the blanks with information from the context. It's a framework, not a word-for-word dictation.
A template can be very strict: "Hello [first name], your invoice from [date] remains unpaid. Please settle before [deadline]." The agent only has to insert the correct values. It can also be flexible: "Politely remind about the unpaid amount, mention the sum, propose a payment plan if needed." Between these two extremes, you adjust the level of freedom.
IIAnd what exactly is free writing?
In free writing, you describe the email's objective without imposing a structure. You tell the agent: "Respond to this customer who is asking for a payment extension, be understanding but firm." The agent chooses the words, the order of ideas, the length. They adapt to the message received. Each response is different, tailored to the situation.
This approach works when situations vary greatly. A consulting firm that responds to very diverse information requests will often prefer free writing. A business that sends the same delivery reminder to all its customers will save time with a template.
IIIThe strengths and limitations of each approach
The template reassures you. You know exactly what's being sent. But if a customer receives three identical reminders in a month, they'll notice. Free writing impresses with its relevance, but it can surprise if the agent misinterprets an instruction. Both have their place.
IVWhen should you prioritize a standardized template?
The standardized model works well in three cases. First, when the message is repetitive and predictable: order confirmations, appointment reminders, acknowledgments of receipt. Next, when the legal framework requires specific notices: follow-ups on unpaid invoices with regulatory deadlines, for example. Finally, when you're starting out with an agent and want to limit surprises.
VWhen should you let the agent write freely?
Free writing shines when each situation is unique. A craftsperson responding to very varied quote requests (kitchen renovation, door installation, emergency repair) cannot anticipate everything in a template. The agent reads the request, understands the context, and writes an adapted response. It's also useful for exchanges where empathy matters: a dissatisfied customer, a delicate request.
VIThe hybrid solution: template with free zones
Most situations benefit from combining both. You define a fixed structure for the parts that don't change (polite formula, signature, legal notices), and you let the agent freely write the core of the message. This is what's called a template with free zones.
- 1Identify the fixed parts
List what never changes: the opening, the signature, the mandatory notices. These elements form the skeleton of the template.
- 2Define free zones
Identify passages that vary depending on context: the body of the message, the proposal, the answer to a question. These zones will be written by the agent.
- 3Write instructions for each zone
For each free zone, specify what the agent should say, the tone to adopt, and the information to include. Be concrete.
- 4Test with a dry run
Run a dry run to see what the agent produces. Adjust the instructions if the result doesn't suit you.
An accounting firm can use this system for its document follow-ups. The opening and signature are fixed. The reminder of missing documents is written by the agent, who adapts the message based on what's actually missing. The client receives a personalized email, but the firm maintains control over the overall tone.
VIIHow to avoid repetition with a template?
Repetition is the main complaint about templates. If a customer receives the same text three times, they may feel like they're talking to a machine. Two solutions exist. The first: create multiple variants of the same template and ask the agent to alternate. The second: insert a free zone for an opening line or personalized detail.
VIIIHow to avoid drift with free writing?
Free writing can produce messages that are too long, too casual, or off-topic. To avoid this, set guardrails in the mission. Specify the maximum length, words or expressions to avoid, information to always include. And above all, keep the manual validation active until you are sure of the result.
At ABYS, the first sends are validated manually. After three validations, you can switch to automatic validation. But nothing requires you to. If you use free writing on sensitive topics, keep manual validation longer.
Check what applies to you: the list remembers your answers on this device.
IXA concrete example: collection of unpaid invoices
Let's take a common case: following up on unpaid invoices. The first reminder can be a strict template, with legal notices and a neutral tone. The second reminder benefits from being more personalized: the agent can recall the customer's history, propose a payment plan if the amount is high, adapt the tone based on the response received. The third reminder, more formal, returns to a template with notice of formal demand mentions.
?Questions we're asked
Can I change my approach midway?
Yes. You can modify your agent's mission at any time. If you started with a template and want more freedom, adjust the instructions. The agent will adapt from the next cycle.
Can the agent mix template and free writing in the same email?
That's exactly the principle of the hybrid template. You fix certain parts, the agent writes the others. It's often the best solution to maintain control without sacrificing personalization.
How do I know if my template is too rigid?
If you receive feedback from customers who find your emails impersonal, or if the agent cannot respond to certain situations, that's a sign. Add a free zone or create variants.
Does free writing consume more tokens?
Generally, yes. The agent thinks more to write an original text. The difference remains modest for short emails, but it can add up with large volumes.
Create your first agent and test the approach that works for you.
Create My AgentRead more next
Chasing unpaid invoices with an AI agent: the step-by-step method
Following up on a late invoice takes little time, but we often put off this unpleasant moment. This tutorial shows how to entrust…
Read the lessonWriting an AI agent's mission: the five-point method
An agent works as well as their mission is clear. This course gives you a five-point method to write it: the goal, the…
Read the lessonDry run of an AI agent: why it's the first step
Before an AI agent sends anything on your behalf, you can see exactly what it would do. The dry run simulates…
Read the lesson